Home / Roofing Resources / Materials & Systems
What Are the Different Types of Asphalt Shingles?
Not all asphalt shingles are the same shingle. The three main types — 3-tab, architectural, and impact-resistant — differ in how they look, how long they last, and how they handle Colorado hail. Here's what each one actually is.
On this page
3-tab shingles: the budget option
3-tab shingles are a single flat layer of asphalt with cutouts that create a repeating three-tab pattern on the roof. They're the least expensive option and the lightest.
The trade-offs: a single layer means thinner protection, shorter service life, and the weakest performance against hail and wind of the three types. In Colorado's hail corridor, 3-tab shingles have the shortest practical life. Most roofers along the Front Range steer homeowners toward architectural shingles or better for this reason.
Architectural (dimensional) shingles: the standard
Architectural shingles — also called laminate or dimensional shingles — bond two or more layers of asphalt together, creating a thicker, textured shingle with a dimensional look. They're the default residential roof across the US for good reason:
- Meaningfully longer service life than 3-tab (roughly a 25–30-year class)
- Better wind resistance (look for high-wind-rated lines)
- Richer appearance that mimics wood shake or slate from the street
- Better hail resistance than 3-tab — though standard architectural shingles still bruise in severe hail
For most Colorado homeowners, architectural shingles are the sensible middle ground. See asphalt shingle roofing in Colorado for the full service picture.
Impact-resistant (Class 4) shingles: the hail upgrade
Class 4 shingles are architectural-style shingles engineered to pass UL 2218, the industry impact-resistance test — surviving strikes from a 2-inch steel ball without fracturing. They're built with reinforced mats (some lines use rubberized asphalt) specifically for hail belts.
They cost more than standard architectural shingles, but in Hail Alley that's money spent exactly where Colorado roofs fail. Some insurers offer discounts for Class 4 roofs — worth asking your agent about. Our dedicated guide explains what Class 4 roofing shingles are and how the rating works.
Talk to a Colorado roofer. Not sure which shingle fits your roof? One call connects you with an independent roofing professional who can inspect your current roof and recommend the right shingle for your Colorado home.
Side-by-side comparison
Think of it as a ladder: 3-tab (cheapest, shortest-lived, weakest in hail) → architectural (the mainstream choice, good balance) → Class 4 impact-resistant (best hail defense among shingles, highest shingle price).
No shingle matches standing-seam metal for raw longevity, but a Class 4 architectural shingle is the strongest shingle play for a Colorado home. Compare materials head-to-head in asphalt shingles vs. metal roofing in Colorado.
Choosing for your roof
Match the shingle to your situation: short-term ownership or tight budget → 3-tab or standard architectural; long-term home in the Front Range hail corridor → Class 4; historic districts with specific look requirements → architectural profiles that mimic the original material. And remember: the installer's quality matters as much as the shingle. Proper roof installation is what lets any shingle reach its rated life.
FAQs
Do I need to tear off old shingles before installing new ones?
Most Colorado jurisdictions allow one overlay layer, but a full tear-off to the deck lets the roofer inspect and repair the decking and underlayment — usually the better long-term choice.
Will my HOA restrict shingle types or colors?
Many Colorado HOAs approve specific shingle profiles and colors. Check your HOA's approved materials list before choosing.
Are 3-tab shingles still a good choice in Colorado?
They're the cheapest option, but their thinner single-layer construction handles hail and wind worse than architectural shingles — a real consideration in Colorado's storm climate.
Related reading
Talk through your shingle options with a roofer
One call connects you with an independent roofing professional for honest advice on the right shingle for your roof — no forms, no sales pressure.
Call Now